Toby Tarnow (born June 15, 1937 in Gravelbourg, Saskatchewan, Canada) is a Canadian actress. She was the first actress to portray the popular Anne Shirley of Anne of Green Gables in Canadian radio then in Canadian television in a 1956 television movie. Her most popular works include the princess on the Canadian Howdy Doody Show, a regular panelist on the Canadian To Tell the Truth, a regular role in CTV'S forensic police drama The Collaborators (1973–74), a regular on the children's show, Mr. Dressup, a continuing character on the American soap opera Moment of Truth, and a continuing role in the miniseries Amerika and a children's television show, Nursery School Time with Miss Toby and Hoppy. In August 1989, she moved to New Hampshire.

In 2012, Toby was awarded the Children's and Youth Theatre Award by the New Hampshire Theatre Awards.